Booktrovert Reader logo featuring black lettering and purple script, representing a fantasy romance and romantasy book review blog.

Honest Book Review of The Mirror of Infinite Endings

Author: Stephanie Garber

Some of the links on this blog are affiliate links, which means I earn a small commission if you make a purchase. This helps support the blog at no extra cost to you. Thank you for your support! Click to read my Disclaimers for more info.

Oh, how I missed Evangeline and Jacks!

After finishing A Curse for True Love, I felt like I didn’t quite get the ending I was hoping for.

After three books of rooting for these two, I wanted more of their happily ever after.

So when Stephanie Garber announced The Mirror of Infinite Endings, I was excited to return to the Magnificent North and see what life looked like for Evangeline and Jacks after everything they went through.

And while this is a novella, there’s more to this story than simply giving fans a happy ending.

Spoiler Warning: This review contains spoilers for the Once Upon a Broken Heart series and The Mirror of Infinite Endings.

Honest romantasy book review of The Mirror of Infinite Endings by Stephanie Garber, featuring a celestial purple book cover and Booktrovert Reader branding.
Book Cover of The Mirror of Infinite Endings by Stephanie Garber

At a Glance ✨

My Rating:
★★★★ 4/5
Spice Level:
No S️pice

What Is The Mirror of Infinite Endings About?

Evangeline and Jacks are living together at the Hollow, preparing for the grand reopening of their magical inn.

Everything seems to be going wonderfully, but there is still one big question surrounding their happily ever after.

Evangeline is mortal. Jacks is not.

What does that mean for their future together?

When Evangeline discovers a magical mirror inside the mysterious Emporium of Else, she is given the opportunity to experience an entirely different version of her life.

But what happens when the life she once dreamed of doesn’t include the Jacks she has grown to love?

Suddenly, their happily ever after doesn’t seem quite as secure as we thought.

Join the Fantasy Chaos ✨

Get romantasy recs, book recaps and bookish chaos delivered straight to your inbox.

No spam, ever. Unsubscribe anytime. Just pure bookish joy.

Finally, More of Evangeline and Jacks!

One of my favorite things about this novella is that we get to see Evangeline and Jacks actually living their lives together.

After all the curses, heartbreak, manipulation, and near-death experiences throughout the original trilogy, seeing them preparing to open an inn together feels like such a different side of their relationship.

It’s a little more domestic, a little cozier, and something I wish we had gotten more of at the end of A Curse for True Love.

The cozy atmosphere of the Hollow makes this such a perfect fall read. Give me a chunky sweater, a warm cup of coffee, and more Evangeline and Jacks, and I’m happy! If you love getting cozy with your books as much as I do, check out my favorite Fall Outfits for Readers for some bookish outfit inspiration.

I’m a sucker for slow burn fantasy romance books, but after spending multiple books waiting for two characters to finally get together, I want to enjoy that payoff!

It’s similar to why I appreciate companion stories like A Court of Frost and Starlight. Sometimes we need a little more time with our favorite characters outside the chaos of the main storyline. You can revisit that story in my A Court of Frost and Starlight book recap.

What If Evangeline Never Fell in Love With Jacks?

The concept behind the Mirror of Infinite Endings is interesting because it allows us to explore what could have happened if Evangeline’s story had taken a completely different direction.

We see a version of Evangeline who doesn’t remember her relationship with Jacks. Her father is still alive, and she has another opportunity at the life she once imagined with Luc.

But knowing everything we know about Evangeline and Jacks makes this scenario so much more complicated.

Would she still choose Jacks without the memories of everything they went through together?

Would Jacks still be drawn to her?

It also gives us another glimpse of the dangerous, emotionally unavailable version of Jacks we originally met.

The idea that these two could find their way back to each other even under entirely different circumstances adds another layer to their romance.

And the appearance of Donatella was a fun connection to the Caraval series!

Stephanie Garber has such a distinctive way of incorporating fairy tale magic into her stories. If you enjoy mysterious magical objects and darker fairy tale elements, I would also recommend checking out my honest book review of One Dark Window.

Jacks and His Fear of Losing Evangeline

One thing I’m glad Stephanie Garber addressed was the difference between Jacks’s immortality and Evangeline’s mortality.

It was a question that still needed answering after the original trilogy.

How can these two truly have a happily ever after when one of them will eventually grow old and the other won’t?

Finding out that Jacks had secretly been looking for a way to stop Evangeline from aging adds so much more meaning to his behavior.

But what makes this even more significant is that when he’s offered a magical bargain, he isn’t willing to risk Evangeline’s safety just so he can have her forever.

Think about how far Jacks has come as a character!

This is someone who spent so much of his story pursuing what he wanted, regardless of the consequences. Now, he’s faced with the opportunity to have an eternity with the woman he loves, but her safety comes first.

We also get to see them confront something they have both been avoiding: what their future together actually looks like.

The Introduction of the Fae

Another interesting addition to The Mirror of Infinite Endings is the introduction of fairy magic and the history of the fae in the Magnificent North.

We already have the Fates, vampires, curses, magical objects, and so many unusual creatures within Stephanie Garber’s world.

Now we get another layer of mythology to explore.

The magical bargains, the dangers of making deals with fairies, and the existence of mirrors that can alter someone’s reality open up so many possibilities for future stories.

It makes me wonder how much more of this world Stephanie Garber still has planned for us.

Evangeline and Jacks Finally Get the Ending I Wanted

THIS is what I wanted from A Curse for True Love!

Not only do we get to see Evangeline and Jacks choose each other again, but we also get a more definite answer about their future.

The magical bargain gives them the opportunity to share a lifetime together without Evangeline growing old while Jacks remains unchanged.

Of course, that opportunity comes with its own consequences, but it gives them a choice about their future.

And Jacks wanting to marry Evangeline?!

YES, PLEASE!

After investing so much time in their relationship, I’m glad we finally got more of the happy ending I was looking for.

Are We Getting a LaLa and Chaos Series?

Okay, can we PLEASE talk about LaLa and Chaos?

Because as much as I loved revisiting Evangeline and Jacks, I’m equally excited about the possibility of another story featuring these two.

LaLa’s complicated history with Dane and her unresolved connection with Chaos have so much potential for another fantasy romance.

There’s already an established history between these characters, but there is still so much we don’t know about their relationship and what could happen next.

And with magical mirrors offering the possibility of changing the past and exploring different outcomes, Stephanie Garber has opened the door to some very interesting storytelling possibilities.

Interestingly, different editions of The Mirror of Infinite Endings feature different bonus endings involving LaLa, which makes me even more curious about what Stephanie Garber is planning.

I would absolutely love an entire series dedicated to LaLa and Chaos.

I’m not ready to say goodbye to the Magnificent North just yet!

My Final Thoughts on The Mirror of Infinite Endings

Overall, I’m giving The Mirror of Infinite Endings 4 out of 5 stars.

I appreciate that Stephanie Garber didn’t simply give us a novella filled with cute moments between Evangeline and Jacks.

We also got answers to lingering questions, further character development, and new possibilities within this magical world.

Most importantly, I finally got more of the ending I had been hoping for after reading A Curse for True Love.

If you finished the original trilogy feeling like you needed a little more closure, I would definitely recommend picking up this novella.

And now I’m going to be patiently (or not so patiently) waiting to see if we get a LaLa and Chaos book!

More Bookish Finds for Romantasy Readers

Still looking for your next fantasy romance obsession? Take my What Type of Romantasy Reader Are You? quiz to discover your reading personality.

📚 This One Deserves a Spot on Your Shelf

Ready to start reading? Grab your copy below.

As an affiliate, I may earn a small commission if you purchase through these links at no extra cost to you. Shopping through Bookshop.org also helps support independent bookstores.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Charity from Booktrovert Reader
💕 SUPPORT BOOKTROVERT READER
Enjoying Booktrovert Reader?
If my reviews, recaps, quizzes, or bookish chaos have made your reading life a little better, you can leave a tip to help me keep creating free, ad-free content.
☕ Leave a Tip
No pressure. I'm just happy you're here. ♡

You might also enjoy

🌶️

Romantasy Spice Book Library

Browse fantasy romance books by spice level, from closed door to "respectfully... what did I just read?"

Explore the Library →