Honest Book Review of Shield of Sparrows
Some of the links on this blog are affiliate links, which means I earn a small commission if you make a purchase. This helps support the blog at no extra cost to you. Thank you for your support! Click to read my Disclaimers for more info.
One Dark Window by Rachel Gillig
The Shepherd King #1
If I had to summarize my experience with One Dark Window in one phrase, itās this: āIt’s me, hi, I’m the problem, it’s meā as the Taylor Swift lyrics would say.Ā This is a fantasy romance book I would say has nothing wrong with it, I just didnāt jive with it.
Elspeth Spindle, the protagonist, constantly walks the tightrope of self-doubt and decisions that ripple through the eerie, magical world of Blunder. Her internal struggles and the eerie bond she shares with the Nightmare, a sentient spirit trapped in her mind, are the heart of this haunting gothic fantasy.
Rachel Gillig weaves a story where the greatest threat to Elspethās survival isnāt just the tyrannical royals or the dark forces surrounding her but the power growing within her. The Nightmare offers her strength and abilities, but at a cost: every decision Elspeth makes tightens its grip on disintegration. As her choices lead her deeper into rebellion, secrets, and unexpected alliances, you canāt help but think, āGirl, you are your own worst enemy.ā And yet, thatās what makes her journey so captivating.
This book doesnāt shy away from dark, atmospheric storytelling, filled with chilling landscapes, an oppressive system, and a romance thatās just as precarious as Elspethās inner turmoil. The found family trope plays beautifully alongside the gothic setting, grounding the story amidst its many twists and betrayals.
Curious what actually makes a book dark fantasy? From morally gray characters and gothic worlds to monsters, magic, and high-stakes romance, my Ultimate Guide to Dark Fantasy breaks it all downāand helps you discover your next obsession.
That being said, One Dark Window just wasn’t my favorite read. That’s not because it’s a bad bookāit definitely isn’t. The writing is beautiful, the world is unique, and you can tell Rachel Gillig put a lot of thought into creating this dark fantasy world. It just didn’t completely click with me.
For me, the pacing slowed down quite a bit in the middle, and I found myself wanting the story to move faster. The gothic fantasy atmosphere was incredibly detailed, but sometimes it felt a little too heavy, and I wanted more moments that pushed the plot forward. I also wasn’t convinced by the romance. It leaned more toward insta-love than I prefer, and I would’ve loved to see the relationship develop more naturally over time. Elspeth also spent a lot of time second-guessing herself, and while it fit her character, I found myself wishing she’d take charge a little sooner.
I can absolutely see why so many readers love One Dark Window, especially if you’re into dark fantasy romance, eerie forests, unique magic systems, and morally gray characters. It just wasn’t the perfect match for my reading taste. And honestly? That’s the fun of books. My three-star read could easily end up being your next five-star obsession.
2 Responses
I totally disagree! I liked the characters and did not want the story to end! I liked the way she described the way the forest, you really felt like you were there! Turmoil between families were the way real life is. I like the history that took you back to how it all started!
I thought about giving the second book a try since I did like the plot. Maybe the second book who pull me in more than the first.