Honest Book Review of Mayhem and the Mortal
Author: Shanora Williams
Some of the links on this blog are affiliate links, which means I earn a small commission if you make a purchase. This helps support the blog at no extra cost to you. Thank you for your support! Click to read my Disclaimers for more info.
Mayhem and the Mortal by Shonora Williams delivered exactly what I was hoping for, an adventurous romantasy filled with danger, magic, and a slow-burn romance that kept me turning the pages. If you love the kind of stories I talk about in my Romantasy VS Romance breakdown or my guide to Top Fantasy Romance Tropes, this one will feel very familiar in the best way.
That said, the beginning did feel a bit jarring. It almost felt like I was dropped straight into the story without much context for what was happening or why. I found myself trying to piece things together in those early chapters instead of fully settling into the world. Once things started to click, though, I became much more invested and was able to enjoy the ride.
The story follows Zaira, a determined and resilient heroine, who will do anything to save her sister from a deadly curse. Her journey alongside Thane—a morally gray assassin with serious red flag energy—was easily one of the highlights of the book. Their dynamic is filled with tension, sharp dialogue, and that addictive push-and-pull you’ll recognize if you love Enemies to Lovers or morally gray characters like the ones I talk about in Shadow Daddies.
I do wish there had been more worldbuilding and stronger character descriptions throughout. You get glimpses of who these characters are, but not always enough to feel fully grounded in them or the environment around them. I especially wanted a clearer picture of Zaira as a main character—both physically and emotionally—because she felt just slightly out of reach at times. If you’re someone who prefers richer, immersive worlds like in Gild, Powerless or The Serpent and the Wings of Night, this is something you may notice too.
The pacing keeps things moving quickly, with high stakes and constant danger that make it feel like a true adventure. And yes—it delivers on the classic one bed trope, which added tension, forced proximity, and just the right push for the romance to develop naturally (always a win if you’re into those tropes like I cover in Ultimate Guide to Spicy Fantasy Romance).
Some emotional moments and character arcs felt a bit rushed, and I would have loved more time spent building those connections. Still, the story as a whole was engaging, entertaining, and easy to get swept up in—especially if you enjoy books like Powerless or One Dark Window.
Final Thoughts: Not perfect, but Mayhem and the Mortal is definitely a fun romantasy read. If you’re exploring your reader type, this would fit right in with my Which Type of Romantasy Reader Are You? quiz.
If You Like This....
If you enjoyed the high-stakes adventure, morally gray characters, and tension-filled romance in this one, I’d also recommend checking out Rings of Fate—it delivers a similar blend of danger, magic, and character-driven storytelling.
Thank you Shonora Williams and Red Tower Books for giving me a copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
