Booktrovert Reader
Honest Book Review of A Court of Splintered Harmony
Author: Sarah J. Maas
Some of the links on this blog are affiliate links, which means I earn a small commission if you make a purchase. This helps support the blog at no extra cost to you. Thank you for your support! Click to read my Disclaimers for more info.
Buckle up ya’ll, I got things to say.
Five years. FIVE YEARS of waiting to return to Prythian, and apparently, everyone has been saving up their unresolved issues just for us. I came for the magic, romance, and chaos.
Instead, I got a front-row seat to the Night Court’s group therapy session. And honestly? I think they need a better therapist.
I have a feeling this book is going to divide ACOTAR fans.
You’re either going to love it because you’re a die-hard Inner Circle fan who could happily read 800 pages of them arguing over breakfast, or you’re going to be severely frustrated waiting for someone, ANYONE, to actually do something about their problems.
Unfortunately, I found myself leaning toward the second group.
Don’t get me wrong, I was excited to be back in Prythian. But A Court of Splintered Harmony left me with some seriously mixed feelings.
A Different Kind of ACOTAR Story
First, this book read very differently from what I’m used to in the A Court of Thorns and Roses series.
Rather than the adventure, romance, and high-stakes storytelling that originally made me fall in love with ACOTAR, this installment felt much more focused on the characters’ internal struggles, strained relationships, and growing tension within the Night Court.
Which, honestly, makes the title Splintered Harmony pretty fitting.
There’s a noticeable shift in the atmosphere. The relationships we’ve watched develop throughout the series aren’t necessarily as comfortable or united as they once seemed.
Old tensions haven’t magically disappeared, and some characters are making it increasingly difficult to root for them.
I appreciate that Sarah J. Maas isn’t pretending everything is sunshine and rainbows after everything these characters have experienced.
But there’s a difference between exploring complicated relationships and spending chapter after chapter discussing the same problems.
And unfortunately, that’s where this book started losing me.
The tension within the Night Court didn’t exactly come out of nowhere. We already started seeing cracks in some of these relationships during A Court of Frost and Starlight. If you need a refresher on where things stood before Nesta’s story, my A Court of Frost and Starlight book recap covers those developments.
The Pacing Was My Biggest Struggle
I STRUGGLED with the beginning of this book.
And I don’t mean a few slow chapters. I mean I was genuinely wondering when the story was going to start moving.
There was SO much talking. Talking about problems, talking about feelings, talking about what needed to happen, and then somehow having another conversation about those exact same problems.
Meanwhile, I’m sitting there thinking, Okay, but are we actually going to DO something about any of this?
I don’t mind slower, character-driven stories. In fact, some of my favorite fantasy books take their time developing relationships and setting up future conflicts.
But I need those conversations to feel like they’re leading somewhere.
Here, too many discussions felt repetitive, and the lack of meaningful progress made the opening portion unnecessarily long.
Thankfully, there were moments later in the book that reminded me why I love this world. I just wish it hadn’t taken so long to get there.
I had a similar frustration with Iron Flame, where I felt the story could have benefited from tighter pacing, even though I was still invested in what came next.
Join the Fantasy Chaos ✨
Get romantasy recs, book recaps and bookish chaos delivered straight to your inbox.
Azriel, We Need to Talk
Oh, Azriel.
I’ve always loved the mysterious, elusive Shadowsinger. The quiet, brooding character who keeps everyone guessing has always been part of his appeal.
But somewhere along the way, that mysterious personality started feeling more like emotional immaturity.
And I never thought I’d say this, but I’m actually losing respect for him.
Instead of the character I’ve admired throughout the series, he’s increasingly coming across as a petulant child.
I understand that he’s complicated and has plenty of unresolved issues, but at some point, I need character development rather than more brooding and questionable behavior.
Being mysterious can only get you so far, sir.
Meanwhile, Lucien and Nesta Are Winning Me Over
Now, here’s something I didn’t necessarily expect: my appreciation for Lucien and Nesta has grown tremendously.
Lucien has been through so much throughout this series, and I find myself rooting for him more than ever.
There’s something about his character that makes me want to see him finally get the happiness and recognition he deserves.
And Nesta? What a turnaround. Looking back at everything she went through in A Court of Silver Flames, it’s interesting to see how much my opinion of her has changed.
If you had told me earlier in the series that she’d become one of the characters I was most invested in, I might have questioned your judgment. But here we are.
I love how my opinions of these characters have changed as the series progresses. Some characters I once adored are frustrating me, while others I previously struggled with have become favorites.
That’s one thing I’ll give Sarah J. Maas credit for: she knows how to make me emotionally invested in fictional people, even when they’re driving me absolutely crazy.
You Really Need to Read Crescent City First
One thing I want to emphasize is how closely this book connects to the Crescent City series.
If you’ve only read ACOTAR, I strongly recommend familiarizing yourself with the events of House of Sky and Breath and also House of Flame and shadow, particularly the aftermath of that storyline, before jumping into this installment.
And can we talk about how many times Bryce was mentioned? I swear her name came up almost as often as the phrase “my mate.” And if you’ve read enough SJM books, you KNOW that’s saying something. 😂
The connections between these worlds are becoming increasingly important, and I think readers who haven’t experienced both series could find themselves missing valuable context.
Personally, I enjoy seeing how Sarah J. Maas is bringing elements of her larger universe together. It’s exciting to consider what these connections could mean for the future.
However, I also understand why some readers might be frustrated that following one series now requires knowledge of another.
Motherhood, Messiness, and All
One thing I genuinely appreciated was how Sarah J. Maas didn’t shy away from depicting motherhood and everything that comes with it.
And I mean EVERYTHING.
Were there moments when I thought, Okay, do we really need another reminder that you’re about to leak breast milk? Absolutely. 😂
But as someone who has breastfed before, I also found those moments incredibly relatable.
Motherhood isn’t always glamorous. There’s the exhaustion, the physical changes, the constant demands of caring for a baby, and the reality that your body doesn’t suddenly go back to being entirely yours.
I actually love that SJM included those details rather than brushing them aside. So often in fantasy, a character has a baby, and we barely see the everyday realities of what comes afterward.
Here, motherhood feels like an actual part of the character’s life rather than something happening conveniently in the background.
And while I might have rolled my eyes at a few of those descriptions, I also couldn’t help thinking, Yep. Been there.
I appreciate that SJM wasn’t afraid to show that even in a magical world like Prythian, motherhood can be beautiful, exhausting, messy, and downright inconvenient. Sometimes all at once.
My Final Thoughts
Despite my frustrations, I don’t think A Court of Splintered Harmony is a bad book.
There are interesting character developments, emotional moments, and enough unanswered questions to make me curious about where this story is heading.
I’ve seen some readers complain that this is simply bad writing, and while I understand where they’re coming from, part of me wonders if we’re missing the bigger picture.
Are we being too quick to judge something that hasn’t fully played out yet?
We know Sarah J. Maas loves to build toward something bigger, and with this story unfolding across multiple installments, I can’t help but wonder if we just need to trust what she’s trying to do.
Maybe all these frustrating conversations, unresolved conflicts, and questionable character decisions are setting us up for something we haven’t even considered yet.
Or maybe I’m just giving SJM the benefit of the doubt because I’ve invested way too much of my life into Prythian at this point. 😂
That being said, I don’t think the promise of a bigger payoff automatically excuses the pacing issues.
After waiting five years for another ACOTAR book, I wanted to feel completely swept away by Prythian again.
Instead, I spent a good portion of the story waiting for the characters to stop talking about their problems and actually do something.
My rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars.
I enjoyed being back in this world, and I’m definitely invested in what happens next. But this wasn’t quite the return to Prythian I had imagined.
Here’s hoping the next installment brings more action, more romance, some much-needed character growth, and perhaps a group therapy session that actually accomplishes something.
Because at this point, I’m trusting the process, Sarah. Please don’t make me regret it.
Need an ACOTAR Refresher Before Diving In?
You've Been Warned.
Everything below contains major spoilers, plot twists, betrayals, and emotional damage.
Well, now that we’ve gotten the polite portion of this review out of the way, can we talk about what actually happened in this book?
Because I have QUESTIONS.
Between Azriel’s questionable decisions, Nesta being treated like she personally invited the Asteri over for dinner, Amren acting like she knows the world is about to end, and the Inner Circle apparently forgetting how to communicate like functioning adults, I have some thoughts.
And not all of them are nice.
Nesta Gave Bryce the Mask. Can We PLEASE Move On?
I understand why the Inner Circle was upset that Nesta handed Bryce the Mask. We’re talking about an incredibly dangerous object that could have had devastating consequences for Prythian.
But here’s my problem: Bryce returned it.
Was Nesta’s decision risky? Absolutely. Did she make that decision without consulting everyone? Yes. But she also helped save an entire world.
And yet, the way Rhysand and the others continue treating her makes it feel like she’s committed some unforgivable betrayal.
What frustrated me even more was Cassian’s reaction.
After everything Nesta and Cassian went through in A Court of Silver Flames, I expected more from their relationship. Watching him distance himself from her, especially when she needed his support, was disappointing.
Their eventual reconciliation was something I appreciated, but I still wanted Cassian to show more understanding of why Nesta made that decision.
And honestly, I think Nesta’s willingness to follow her instincts, even when everyone disagrees with her, might turn out to be far more important than anyone realizes.
Azriel, Sir, What Are You Doing?
I never expected to be this frustrated with Azriel.
For years, his mysterious personality was one of the things that made him so interesting. I mean, I’ve always had a weakness for a good shadow daddy, and Azriel practically helped define the obsession.
For years, his mysterious personality was one of the things that made him so interesting. But finally getting inside his head made me question whether I actually liked the man behind all that brooding.
His relationship with Elain is messy enough, but continuing to pursue her while she’s still mated to Lucien, knowing the political and personal consequences, felt incredibly selfish.
And then Lucien catches them.
THE AUDACITY.
I understand that Elain has the right to choose whom she loves. A mating bond shouldn’t automatically dictate her future. But there’s a difference between exercising that choice and allowing someone else to be humiliated in the process.
What bothered me most was Azriel’s attitude toward the situation. Rather than taking responsibility, he seemed determined to make everything worse.
And sending Erebos to spy on Lucien afterward?
Azriel. Please.
At some point, the mysterious Shadowsinger becomes the emotionally immature man who refuses to deal with the consequences of his actions.
Lucien Deserves Better
I have become such a Lucien supporter.
Watching him discover what’s happening between Elain and Azriel was heartbreaking, especially considering everything he’s already endured.
I don’t believe Elain owes Lucien a romantic relationship simply because they’re mates. But I do believe he deserves honesty and respect.
And listen, I love a good forbidden love fantasy romance as much as the next romantasy reader. Give me the tension, the impossible choices, and all the emotional chaos. But there’s a difference between forbidden love and treating someone like their feelings don’t matter.
And the wooden rabbit he gives Feyre, carved by their father before his death? That small gesture reminded me how much quiet thoughtfulness Lucien brings to this series.
I’m genuinely hoping SJM has something wonderful planned for him.
Whether that involves Elain or someone entirely different, I just want this man to find some happiness.
Preferably far away from the Night Court’s never-ending drama.
Azriel's Shadows Might Be Telling Us Something
Now THIS is something I’m interested in.
Azriel’s shadows actively avoiding Elain while responding differently to Gwyn feels far too deliberate to ignore.
We’ve spent years debating whether Azriel belongs with Elain or Gwyn, but what if his shadows have been giving us clues all along?
And then there’s Truth-Teller.
The fact that Azriel feels disconnected from his own blade after Bryce’s involvement, combined with the references to its song, makes me wonder whether his storyline is about something much bigger than romance.
Maybe we’re watching Azriel lose his sense of identity before he’s forced to discover who he actually is.
That would be an interesting character arc.
But please, Sarah, can we get there without another 200 pages of him sulking?
And speaking of shadows, at this point, I’m tempted to make Azriel take my Who’s Your Shadow Daddy? quiz just to see if he still qualifies. Because sir, your shadows seem to have better judgment than you do.
The Prison, Nesta, and the Bigger Picture
Of all the storylines, Nesta’s connection to the Prison might be the one I’m most excited about.
Her growing abilities, her connection to Gwydion, and the mysterious presence calling to her suggest there’s something much larger happening beneath the surface.
And the Prison taking Gwydion from her?
EXCUSE ME?
Between the history of the Dusk Court, the weapons, and everything Bryce uncovered in Crescent City, I can’t imagine these connections are accidental.
I also find it interesting that Nesta continues being drawn toward these mysteries while the Inner Circle remains so focused on its internal conflicts.
What if Nesta is the one being positioned to uncover something that changes everything?
Bryaxis and Nyx's Naming Ceremony
I was not prepared for Bryaxis to return like THAT.
A celebration for Nyx turning into an absolute nightmare was one of the moments that finally made the stakes feel real.
And the possibility that Koschei’s influence is connected to Bryaxis raises even more questions.
What exactly is Koschei planning? How much of what’s happening has already been manipulated? And are the Inner Circle’s disagreements making them vulnerable to something much worse?
This was the kind of danger and uncertainty I’d been waiting for throughout the book.
Elain Leaving for Vallahan
I actually think Elain leaving with Mor might be one of the best things that could happen for her character.
For so long, Elain has been defined by her relationships with other people. Her sisters, her mating bond with Lucien, and now her feelings for Azriel.
Maybe getting away from the Night Court is exactly what she needs.
I’m curious whether we’ll finally see Elain develop an identity outside of the men surrounding her.
And considering her abilities as a Seer, I have a feeling her involvement in Vallahan could become much more important than anyone expects.
Amren Knows Something, and I Have a Bad Feeling About It
Okay, can we talk about Amren for a minute?
Because something is OFF with her.
I’ve always known Amren to be blunt, secretive, and a little terrifying. That’s nothing new. But throughout this book, I couldn’t shake the feeling that she’s aware of something much bigger happening. Something ominous that she either can’t speak about or doesn’t know how to explain.
And honestly? That’s more unsettling than anything else.
Amren has existed for thousands of years. She’s seen civilizations rise and fall, witnessed ancient powers at work, and knows more about Prythian’s history than practically anyone. So when someone like her starts acting differently, I PAY ATTENTION.
Especially when it comes to Nesta, the Prison, and Gwydion.
The way Amren seems to be pushing certain events forward makes me wonder whether she’s recognizing signs of something she’s encountered before. Almost like she’s watching pieces fall into place and already knows what happens when they do.
What if she knows something terrible is coming but isn’t able to warn anyone directly? Could there be ancient magic, a forgotten prophecy, or something connected to her past that prevents her from revealing what she knows?
Or maybe she doesn’t have the full picture herself. Maybe she’s just recognizing something that the others haven’t caught on to yet.
I don’t think Amren is secretly working against the Inner Circle. I think she might be genuinely afraid of what’s coming.
And if Amren, of all people, has reason to be afraid, what exactly are we dealing with?
There’s something about her behavior that feels less like manipulation and more like someone desperately trying to prepare everyone for a storm they can’t see yet.
I could be completely overthinking this, but I refuse to believe SJM is drawing attention to Amren’s reactions without a reason.
Because if the ancient, terrifying woman who rarely seems rattled knows something we don’t?
Well, that certainly doesn’t make me feel better about Prythian’s future.
Are We Watching the Inner Circle Fall Apart for a Reason?
This is where I keep coming back to the title.
Splintered Harmony.
What if SJM isn’t simply writing a story about characters who can’t get along?
What if she’s intentionally dismantling the relationships we’ve spent five books watching her build?
Rhysand’s leadership is being questioned. Nesta and Cassian’s relationship has been tested. Azriel is making increasingly reckless decisions. Elain is leaving. Even Feyre and Amren have struggled to see eye to eye.
The Night Court doesn’t feel nearly as united as it once did.
And perhaps that’s the entire point.
If Koschei is preparing to strike, what better time than when the people responsible for protecting Prythian can barely agree on anything?
But now I’m wondering whether there’s another layer to all of this.
What if Amren already senses the danger? What if Nesta’s connection to the Prison, Azriel’s changing relationship with his shadows, and Elain’s visions are all pieces of something much bigger?
Maybe we’re watching the Inner Circle fracture at the exact moment they need each other most.
Or maybe these characters need to be pushed apart before they can discover who they’re supposed to become.
I’m not convinced all of these conflicts are accidental.
And while I understand why some readers are calling this bad writing, I keep coming back to the possibility that SJM is deliberately making us uncomfortable.
We’ve grown used to the Inner Circle being this powerful, almost untouchable family. Perhaps she’s reminding us that even the strongest relationships can crack under enough pressure.
The question is whether those cracks will eventually heal or become something much more dangerous.
I’m hoping the next installment gives us enough answers to justify how much time we’ve spent watching everyone argue.
Because Sarah, I trust that you’re building toward something.
📚 This One Deserves a Spot on Your Shelf
Ready to start reading? Grab your copy below.




